10 Indian soldiers including two Majors released by Chinese army; Lt. Gen (Retd) Panag corrects foreign minister on controversy over Indian soldiers approaching Chinese unarmed


The Indian army has said that all 10 soldiers including two senior officers had been released by the Chinese army after intense negotiations. The army said that all soldiers involved in the deadly clashes with the Chinese army in the Galwan valley of eastern Ladakh had been accounted for and no more Indian troops were missing in action.

News agency PTI reported, “Ten Indian Army personnel including two Majors were released by the Chinese military on Thursday evening following three days of negotiations, people familiar with the development said.”

At least 20 Indian soldiers including one Colonel B Santosh Babu were killed by the Chinese soldiers on Monday after they reportedly attempted to push the enemy troops away from the Indian territory. According to the Indian army, as many as 76 soldiers were assaulted by the Chinese army on Monday. Of which, 18 soldiers are currently undergoing treatment at a hospital in Leh.

The development left the Centre’s Narendra Modi government red-faced since it has been denying the presence of the Chinese army on the Indian soil for weeks. The death of 20 Indian soldiers exposed the government’s claims. Congress MP Rahul Gandhi lashed out at Prime Minister Narendra Modi as he asked, “How dare China kill our UNARMED soldiers? Why were our soldiers sent UNARMED to martyrdom?”

In his subsequent tweet, he wrote, “It’s now crystal clear that: 1. The Chinese attack in Galwan was pre-planned. 2. GOI was fast asleep and denied the problem. 3. The price was paid by our martyred Jawans.”

External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar responded, “Let us get the facts straight. All troops on border duty always carry arms, especially when leaving post. Those at Galwan on 15 June did so. Long-standing practice (as per 1996 & 2005 agreements) not to use firearms during faceoffs.”

However, Lt. General HS Panag said that the agreements cited by Jaishankar were only applicable to border management and ‘not while dealing with a tactical military situation.’ He wrote, “Article 6 of 1996 Agreement! These agreements apply to border management and not while dealing with a tactical military situation. Lastly, when the lives of soldiers or security of post/territory threatened, Cdr on the spot can use all weapons at his disposal including Artillery.”

The last time the Chinese military had taken Indian soldiers captive was in July 1962 after a clash in Galwan Valley. At least 30 Indian soldiers were killed and several dozens were captured by Chinese military after the fierce clash.